Now, I probably would have given this a 4, but my wife insisted on a 5 as it has by far been her absolute favorite! My biggest thing is that I wish my maple flavor was a bit more impactful. What you get is a warm buttery bread flavor with a hint of maple. To me, that translates as a cheap store bought "butter" flavored maple syrup, on top of a really solid french toast. And as such it left me wanting a bit stronger/more natural maple flavor. To each their own, but this one is very good.